Aristotle’s Criticism of Presocratic Philosophy · Harold F. Cherniss. New York: Octagon Books (). Abstract, This article has no associated abstract. (fix it). Harold F. Cherniss [was] a specialist in ancient Greek philosophy who wrote many books and articles in his field and was an editor and translator of volumes. Harold Cherniss () was an American Classicist. A highly renowned academic, Cherniss received his Ph.D. in Greek, Latin, and Sanskrit from the.

Author: Dashakar Gogore
Country: Guatemala
Language: English (Spanish)
Genre: Travel
Published (Last): 16 March 2011
Pages: 84
PDF File Size: 3.87 Mb
ePub File Size: 5.57 Mb
ISBN: 267-8-77820-755-8
Downloads: 59902
Price: Free* [*Free Regsitration Required]
Uploader: Gajar

Lewis Strauss sought to have Oppenheimer fired:. John Bigelow – manuscript. Jones readily adopted Shorey’s views of Plato’s teachings, stressing the unity of Plato’s thought from the Apology and Crito down to the Lawsand opposing the Burnet-Taylor school, which saw a ccherniss change in Plato’s thought after the Republic This article has no associated abstract.

Sign in to use this feature.

Harold F. Cherniss

cherhiss The First Century ,’p. Recollection and the Mathematician’s Method in Plato’s Meno. Kafkasfriend rated it really liked it Dec 13, Cherniss’s landmark monograph transformed studies of Pre-Socratic philosophy by forcing scholars to re-evaluate their sources and raise the rigor of their arguments. Atlantic Books,pp. After the war, … Lt. Sign in Create an account. Cherniss first met Oppenheimer at Berkeley in Grundlegung einer Geschichte seiner Entwicklung ; English trans.

Selected Papers

Alan Kim – – Academia. Cherniss saw both contentions under attack by the “higher critics” of Plato scholarship in his day.

It was a declaration to have no experimental science, no laboratories of any kind at the Institute. After talking with a few trustees, Cherniss had realized that Oppenheimer’s job was in doubt.


A colleague at Berkeley remarked ‘He is a Platonist both as scholar and as thinker Hitler invaded Poland on September 1, In Briggs, Ward W. Secondly, it’s harodl kind of paradox you could play with till the cows come home.

Harold Cherniss, Plato as Mathematician – PhilPapers

The American Journal of Philology. Online, accessed January 9,at http: Aaron Sloman – manuscript. This was the basic reason for the break-up of the coalition … the election of 20 May was a clear success for the left-wing … [the DNVP’s] strength in the Reichstag fell from to Oppenheimer’s mastery of these histrionic moves was incredible.

He was still sharp and I was pleased to be able to discuss Plato with him … [54]. Request removal from index. It is easy enough to see the vulnerabilities of each approach.

Strong, online, accessed 5 Januaryat http: A personal letter of Kantowriciz noted that ‘Ruth [Cherniss] has been operated on gynaecol. Anti-semitism was still widespread at this time in America even at universities like Princeton, but the Institute ’employed scholars with absolutely no regard to religious persuasion or ethnicity.

Cherniss is the sort of scholar where one needs to know a lot about the topic to fully appreciate. Afterwards Chsrniss invited me to his beautiful office and, as we started chatting, Oppenheimer came into the room and sat on the table behind us.

Oppenheimer later claimed to have said those words but there is no contemporary evidence. He spent most of his time maintaining his elaborate bibliography of Plato, carefully entering the information on each new book and article on an index card. From the passages thus far considered there emerge certain general tendencies of Aristotle’s critical method … Essential distinctions among various Academic theories are likely to be disregarded, and a criticism pertinent to one form of a given doctrine may be applied to all of its variations … and, finally, a doctrine may be attacked in a form which is the result of Aristotle’s own chernisss and formulation … [76].


It is opposed, for example, to ‘developmentalism’ that holds Plato’s doctrines evolved through the cherinss in which he wrote the dialogues. Before and after World War II, various circumstances intertwined the careers of Cherniss and his friend Robert Oppenheimerthe director of the Manhattan Project that developed the atom bombs dropped on Hiroshima and Nagasaki.

He was assigned to a British intelligence unit in England, France and Belgium, and rose to the rank of captain in three years. This page was last edited on 13 Decemberat But since the dialogues are not obviously completely From the Publisher via CrossRef no proxy Setup an account with your affiliations in order to access resources via your University’s proxy server Configure custom proxy use this if your affiliation does not provide a proxy.

Oppenheimer was later suspected of being a Soviet spy and lost his security clearance in the ensuing national scandal. Landry – – Philosophia Mathematica 20 2: Kraemer, Arete bei Platon und Aristoteles, in Chernisv. Return to Book Page.